Legacy Homeware

An illustration, not a photo. We only show photos of the piece itself once the maker gives permission.

Kitchen · Cast iron

5.5 qt Dutch Oven

by Smithey, USA

✓ Bare cast iron✓ Re-seasonable✓ Lifetime guarantee5 of 5 verified

Where to buy

Smithey · $300Visit maker →

Price checked . We may earn a commission from this link; it never decides what we include.

Why it's an heirloom

Smithey's Dutch oven is bare cast iron, with no enamel to chip or craze. It seasons with use, like the brand's skillets.

Material
Bare cast iron
Maker
Smithey
Maker based in
USA
Made in
USA
Warranty
Lifetime guarantee
Price band
Mid (about $300–1,500)

On our lists: No. 2 in the kitchen · Heirloom gifts for the cook · Housewarming and wedding gifts that last

The Heirloom Standard

How this piece measures up

5 of 5 tests verified

  • 1. Solid materialsPasses. Solid cast iron; no plating and no nonstick coating.
  • 2. Built to be repairedPasses. If it rusts or loses its seasoning, scrub it back and re-season it.
  • 3. Ages wellPasses. The seasoning darkens and improves with use.
  • 4. Lasting designPasses. The lidded Dutch oven.
  • 5. Maker stands behind itPasses. Lifetime guarantee.
  • Made in (not one of the five tests)USA

“Partial” means we've confirmed it and it falls short of what we'd like (a short or finish-only warranty, for example). “Not yet verified” means we haven't confirmed it from the maker yet, not that the piece fails. How we evaluate

More from Kitchen

Pieces worth keeping