Fireplace tools and andirons that last for generations
Updated · 12 picks, ranked · Prices as listed Oct 18, 2026
Fireplace tools
The short answer
What fireplace tools last a lifetime?
Solid forged iron or steel, made by a blacksmith. Urban Forge's Meadow five-piece set ranks first: forged iron that the maker guarantees forever (the broom is covered for a year), and it passes all five of our tests. For andirons, Pilgrim's blacksmith-style pair passes all five at $239, and Ponderosa Forge's hand-forged ring andirons are our pick to hand down. Avoid plated and hollow-tube sets.
How we ranked
First by the Heirloom Standard: a piece that verifiably passes more of the five tests always ranks higher. Small forges often don't publish a warranty, so the fifth test is still open for several pieces here. Among pieces that verify the same tests, a published guarantee ranks higher, then a confirmed place of making, and the rest is our judgement, explained in each entry.
Every fact comes from the maker's or retailer's own pages, checked Oct 18, 2026; we haven't tested these side by side. How we evaluate. We may earn a commission from some links; it never decides what's included or where it ranks.
Tool sets and pokers
Number 1The set to buy once
Urban Forge Meadow Tool Set, 5 pc
Five pieces forged in iron by a US blacksmith shop that guarantees its iron forever; the broom, the one part that wears out, is covered for a year. It verifies all five tests.
Choose it ifyou use the fireplace all winter and want the whole set done once.
- Material
- Forged iron
- Made in
- USA
- Warranty
- Iron "Guaranteed Forever"; broom covered 1 year
- Standard
- 5 of 5 verified
Number 2The poker
Urban Forge Square Loop Fire Poker
One piece of hand-forged iron with a square loop handle, from the same shop and with the same forever guarantee on the iron, at $99. If the fireplace already has tools, this is the one to upgrade first.
- Material
- Hand-forged iron
- Made in
- USA
- Warranty
- Iron "Guaranteed Forever"
- Standard
- 5 of 5 verified
Number 3Trip-hammer forged
Ponderosa Forge Lodge Fireplace Tool Set
A full fireplace tool set from Ponderosa Forge in Sisters, Oregon, shaped under a trip hammer, the power hammer blacksmiths have relied on for generations. We haven't verified the warranty yet.
- Material
- Trip-hammer forged
- Made in
- Sisters, Oregon, USA
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Andirons and grates
Number 4Best value
Pilgrim Blacksmith Andirons
A pair of blacksmith-style iron andirons, finished in paint, with a limited lifetime guarantee: at $239, the only andirons here that verify all five tests.
- Material
- Iron, painted
- Made in
- Not yet verified
- Warranty
- Limited Lifetime Guarantee
- Standard
- 5 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't confirmed whether these are forged or cast.
Number 5To hand down
Ponderosa Forge Ring Andirons
Hand-forged iron with ring tops, the top of Ponderosa Forge's range on our list, made in Sisters, Oregon. We haven't verified the warranty yet.
Choose it ifthe fireplace is the centre of the room.
- Material
- Hand-forged iron
- Made in
- Sisters, Oregon, USA
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Number 6The grate
Ponderosa Forge Hand-Forged Fireplace Grate
Solid 1-inch bar, forged by hand in Oregon rather than stamped: the simplest hearth piece there is, heavy iron and nothing else.
- Material
- Solid 1" forged bar
- Made in
- Sisters, Oregon, USA
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't confirmed the warranty yet.
Number 7Colonial pattern
Rumford Colonial Andirons
Hand-forged steel in a Colonial pattern, among the oldest hearth forms still being made. They sit below the Ponderosa pieces because where they're made is still open.
- Material
- Hand-forged steel
- Made in
- Not yet verified
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't confirmed where they're made or the warranty.
Number 8Spade tops
Rumford Spade Topped Andirons
Hand-forged steel andirons topped with spade-shaped finials, from the same seller as the Colonial pair.
- Material
- Hand-forged steel
- Made in
- Not yet verified
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't confirmed where they're made or the warranty.
Screens, fenders and log holders
Number 9Made to measure
Urban Forge Custom Iron Fire Screen
A single-panel screen with feet, hand-forged in iron and made to the size of your opening, with Urban Forge's forever guarantee on the iron.
- Material
- Hand-forged iron
- Made in
- USA
- Warranty
- Iron "Guaranteed Forever"
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't yet confirmed what the mesh is made of.
Number 10For the woodpile
Ponderosa Forge Half Round Log Rack
A half-round log rack of forged bar joined with rivets, the blacksmith's traditional joint, from Ponderosa Forge in Oregon. We haven't verified the warranty yet.
- Material
- Riveted forged bar
- Made in
- Sisters, Oregon, USA
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Number 11To carry the wood in
Duluth Pack Log Carrier
Canvas and riveted leather from Duluth Pack in Minnesota. Both materials soften with use and can be mended rather than thrown away.
- Material
- Canvas + riveted leather
- Made in
- Minnesota, USA (per the maker's site)
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingWe haven't confirmed the warranty yet.
Number 12Solid brass at the hearth
Fireplace Treatments RF70 Solid Brass Double Rail Fender
A double-rail fender made by hand in 100% solid brass in the USA. With solid brass there's no plating to wear through as it's polished.
- Material
- 100% solid brass, handmade
- Made in
- Hand crafted in USA
- Warranty
- Not yet verified
- Standard
- 4 of 5 verified
Worth knowingIt's priced by custom quote; the "from" price is a starting point.
Made to order; final price by custom quote.
The makers at a glance
What we've verified for each maker, from the pieces we've checked.
Urban Forge
- Made in
- USA
- How it's made
- Hand-forged and forged iron
- Guarantee, as published
- Iron "Guaranteed Forever"; broom covered for 1 year
Ponderosa Forge
- Made in
- Sisters, Oregon, USA
- How it's made
- Hand-forged and trip-hammer forged iron
- Guarantee, as published
- Not yet verified
Pilgrim
- Made in
- Not yet verified
- How it's made
- Painted iron; forged or cast not yet confirmed
- Guarantee, as published
- Limited Lifetime Guarantee
Rumford
- Made in
- Not yet verified
- How it's made
- Hand-forged steel
- Guarantee, as published
- Not yet verified
Fireplace Treatments
- Made in
- USA
- How it's made
- Handmade in 100% solid brass
- Guarantee, as published
- Not yet verified
Duluth Pack
- Made in
- Minnesota, USA
- How it's made
- Canvas and riveted leather
- Guarantee, as published
- Not yet verified
| Maker | Made in | How it's made | Guarantee, as published |
|---|---|---|---|
| Urban Forge | USA | Hand-forged and forged iron | Iron "Guaranteed Forever"; broom covered for 1 year |
| Ponderosa Forge | Sisters, Oregon, USA | Hand-forged and trip-hammer forged iron | Not yet verified |
| Pilgrim | Not yet verified | Painted iron; forged or cast not yet confirmed | Limited Lifetime Guarantee |
| Rumford | Not yet verified | Hand-forged steel | Not yet verified |
| Fireplace Treatments | USA | Handmade in 100% solid brass | Not yet verified |
| Duluth Pack | Minnesota, USA | Canvas and riveted leather | Not yet verified |
Forged, cast or tube
Forged iron is heated and hammered into shape, by hand or under a power hammer. It's solid all the way through, tough rather than brittle, and a smith can straighten it if it's ever bent. Cast iron is poured into a mould: strong and heavy, good for andirons and grates, but it can crack if it's struck hard or doused with water while hot. Most inexpensive tool sets are neither: they're thin steel tube with a painted or plated finish, and they're the ones that bend and flake.
What a set needs
A poker, a shovel, a brush and a stand at the least; tongs are worth having for moving logs. The brush is the one part that wears out, which is why Urban Forge covers its broom for a year and its iron forever. Look for a brush head that can be replaced, and handles long enough to keep your hand out of the heat.
Measure first
Andirons, grates and screens have to suit the fireplace. Measure the width and height of the opening and the depth of the firebox before you order, and leave room around the fire for air. Made-to-measure pieces such as Urban Forge's screen are built to your opening, so they take longer to arrive.
Keeping them
Forged iron indoors needs very little: wipe it dry, and once or twice a year rub on a thin coat of paste wax or oil and buff it off. Surface rust comes off with steel wool. Keeping forged iron from rust has the method.
Questions
Are hand-forged fireplace tools worth it?
If you use the fireplace, yes. Forged iron is solid all the way through, so it doesn't bend like hollow-tube sets or flake like plated ones, and it can be reshaped if it's ever bent. On our list, a hand-forged poker is $99 and full forged sets are $752 and $825.
What should a fireplace tool set include?
A poker, a shovel, a brush and a stand at the least; tongs are useful for moving logs. The brush is the part that wears out, so choose a set whose brush head can be replaced.
Forged or cast iron andirons?
Both are solid, and both last generations in normal use. Forged andirons are hammered from bar and are tough; cast andirons are poured in a mould and are heavy, but can crack if they're struck hard or doused with water while hot.
How do you keep fireplace tools from rusting?
Keep them dry, and once or twice a year rub on a thin coat of paste wax or oil and buff it off. If rust appears, take it off with steel wool, then oil and wax. Indoors, that's all forged iron needs.